IcePath icepath.io · Hockey Analytics
← New Search ↗ Social Card

Erick Comstock Elite Prospects ↗

Position: Defense DOB: 2005-03-14 Country: USA
Augustana
CCHA D1

Set Commitment

NCAA Division I

NCAA D3 / D2

Career Trajectory
Dashed = raw PPG  ·  ■ Solid blue = age-adjusted NCAAe-PPG  ·  ■ Green = actual college PPG
Junior Seasons
Season Team League GP G A Pts PPG NCAAe-PPG Age-Adj D3e-PPG Age-Adj
2021-22 Warroad USHS-MN 31 4 31 35 1.129 0.1429 0.1429 0.2742 0.2742
2022-23 Wisconsin Windigo NAHL 6 0 1 1 0.167 0.0612 0.0665 0.1760 0.1913
2023-24 Wisconsin Windigo NAHL 59 9 35 44 0.746 0.2740 0.2848 0.7872 0.8182
2024-25 Chicago Steel USHL 60 0 6 6 0.100 0.0590 0.0556 0.3003 0.2831
2025-26 Watertown Shamrocks NAHL 47 4 31 35 0.745 0.2736 0.2565 0.7860 0.7370
■ Blue = NCAAe (D1 anchor)   ■ Green = D3e (D3 anchor)   COVID-flagged seasons highlighted in yellow

College Pathway Likelihood (based on 40 comparables)

32%
NCAA D1
10%
NCAA D2/D3
28%
Age-Out / Club
30%
Pro / Other

NCAAe Rankings

#5615
Defenseman overall
#1412
Defenseman born in 2005

D1 Comparables

Marc-Antoine Carrier
QMJHL · 2012-13 · 0.37 PPG
→ Brown (0.04 D1 FR PPG)
0.16 Developing D
NCAAe PPG
Dominic Racobaldo
USHL · 2012-13 · 0.33 PPG
→ American International (0.12 D1 FR PPG)
0.18 Developing D
NCAAe PPG
Brandon Carlson
USHL · 2012-13 · 0.24 PPG
→ Alabama-Huntsville (0.11 D1 FR PPG)
0.13 Developing D
NCAAe PPG
Matt Krug
USHL · 2012-13 · 0.21 PPG
→ Union (0.11 D1 FR PPG)
0.11 Developing D
NCAAe PPG
Benjamin Gallacher
USHL · 2012-13 · 0.45 PPG
→ Ohio State (0.50 D1 FR PPG)
0.24 Elite D
NCAAe PPG

Augustana Alumni similar profiles who attended this school

Easton Young
USHS-MN 2021-22
0.39
actual FR PPG at Augustana
Will Svenddal
USHS-MN 2019-20
0.10
actual FR PPG at Augustana
Carter Theissen
USHS-MN 2020-21
0.00
actual FR PPG at Augustana
Ethan Perrault
NAHL 2022-23
0.00
actual FR PPG at Augustana

D2/3 Comparables

Brandon Couto
SUNY Potsdam · 2009-10
0.591 Average
actual D2/3 PPG
Ethan James
Wisconsin-Superior · 2015-16
1.000 Elite
actual D2/3 PPG
Will Soloway
Colby · 2023-24
0.750 Strong
actual D2/3 PPG

How to read this: NCAAe and D3e factors convert a player's junior PPG into expected NCAA scoring at the D1 or D3 level. Harder conferences → lower projected PPG for the same player. A strong junior player (e.g. USHL 0.90 PPG) will project much higher in NESCAC than Big Ten because the D3 scoring environment is lower-difficulty.

Strength factor: conferences above 1.0 are harder than average; below 1.0 are easier. The formula is: Base NCAAe PPG ÷ Conference Strength = Projected PPG.